New York vs Miami: Full Comparison
Updated November 2026 · Cost of living, safety, and climate data
Quick Answer
New York is 31% more expensive than Miami. New York is 54% safer. Miami has more comfortable months (7 vs 6). New York population: 8,584,629. Miami population: 489,812.
Which city is better for you?
Based on cost of living indices, FBI crime data, and NOAA climate records.
Cost of Living: New York vs Miami
Miami is more affordable overall, with a cost of living index of 145 vs 190 (national average = 100). That's a difference of 45 index points.
| Category | New York | Miami |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Index | 190 | 145 |
| Housing | $5,340/moIndex: 300 | $4,094/moIndex: 230 |
| Groceries | $472/moIndex: 115 | $443/moIndex: 108 |
| Transportation | $438/moIndex: 125 | $385/moIndex: 110 |
| Healthcare | $358/moIndex: 112 | $346/moIndex: 108 |
| Utilities | $220/moIndex: 100 | $220/moIndex: 100 |
Index 100 = national average. Dollar amounts are estimated monthly costs. Sources: BEA Regional Price Parities, C2ER Cost of Living Index.
Safety: New York vs Miami
New York is 54% safer overall, with a crime rate of 19.8 per 1,000 residents vs Miami's 43.5. New York earns a B- safety grade compared to Miami's F. Based on 2023 FBI data.
New York
New York
Miami
Florida
| Metric | New York | Miami |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Crime Rate | 19.8/1K | 43.5/1K |
| Violent Crime Rate | 380.0 | 550.0 |
| Property Crime Rate | 1600.0 | 3800.0 |
| Murder Rate | 5.8 | 6.9 |
| Assault Rate | 307.2 | 447.8 |
| Robbery Rate | 78.0 | 96.0 |
| Burglary Rate | 209.6 | 642.6 |
| Theft Rate | 1317.5 | 2529.9 |
| Vehicle Theft Rate | 222.6 | 558.7 |
Crime rates per 100,000 residents. 2023 FBI Uniform Crime Report data. Lower rates are better (safer).
Victim Odds
In New York, you have a 1 in 51 chance of being a crime victim per year vs 1 in 23 in Miami.
Climate: New York vs Miami
New York Climate Overview
Miami Climate Overview
Monthly Temperature Comparison
| Metric | New York | Miami |
|---|---|---|
| Avg Annual High | 62.7°F | 84.6°F |
| Avg Annual Low | 47.3°F | 71°F |
| Annual Rain | 49.0" | 61.7" |
| Annual Snow | 24.8" | None |
| Comfortable Months | 6 | 7 |
| Freezing Months | 3 | 0 |
Miami is 6°F warmer in summer than New York, but New York is 36°F colder in winter than Miami. New York gets 25 inches of snow annually, while Miami rarely sees any. Miami is wetter with 62" of annual rain compared to 49". Miami has more comfortable weather months (7 vs 6).
Frequently Asked Questions
Is New York cheaper than Miami?
Is New York safer than Miami?
Which city has better weather, New York or Miami?
Should I move to New York or Miami?
How big is New York compared to Miami?
Is housing cheaper in New York or Miami?
Learn More About Each City
Safety data: 2023 FBI Uniform Crime Report. Cost of living: BEA Regional Price Parities and C2ER Cost of Living Index. Climate: NOAA 30-year normals. Not a substitute for local guidance.
Know before you go
CityCheck covers safety, cost of living, climate, and things to do for every US city.
Explore cities