CityCheckCityCheck
Updated November 2026

10 Safest Cities in New York (2026)

The safest city in New York is West Haverstraw with a crime rate of 18.3 per 1,000 residents and a B safety grade. Kenmore (19/1K) and Watertown (19.3/1K) round out the top three. Rankings cover 90 cities using FBI crime data.

Updated November 2026 · 90 cities ranked · FBI UCR data

As of 2026, New York State's crime picture extends well beyond New York City. Upstate cities like Rochester and Syracuse have their own crime challenges, while many suburban communities are exceptionally safe.

New York vs National Average

Avg Crime Rate
22.5per 1K

National avg: 22.0/1K(3% higher)

Avg Violent Crime
379per 100K

National avg: 363.8(4% higher)

Avg Property Crime
1875per 100K

National avg: 1,832.3(2% higher)

10 Safest Cities in New York

All 90 Cities Ranked by Safety

#CityGradeCrime/1K
1West Haverstraw
B
18.3
2Kenmore
B
19
3Watertown
B-
19.3
4Babylon
B-
19.3
5Mount Kisco
B-
19.7
6New York
B-
19.8
7Peekskill
B-
19.8
8Lynbrook
B-
19.8
9Suffern
B-
20.1
10Long Beach
B-
20.3
11Endicott
B-
20.3
12Plattsburgh
B-
20.4
13Oneonta
B-
20.4
14Fulton
B-
20.4
15Binghamton
B-
20.5
16Saratoga Springs
B-
20.5
17East Rockaway
B-
20.5
18Niagara Falls
B-
20.6
19North Tonawanda
B-
20.7
20Tarrytown
B-
20.7
21Freeport
B-
20.8
22Rome
B-
20.8
23Glens Falls
B-
21
24Great Neck
B-
21.1
25Batavia
B-
21.2
26Beacon
B-
21.2
27Woodbury
B-
21.2
28Patchogue
B-
21.3
29Garden City
B-
21.4
30Johnson City
B-
21.4
31Valley Stream
B-
21.5
32Mamaroneck
B-
21.5
33Airmont
B-
21.5
34Kingston
B-
21.6
35Depew
B-
21.6
36Mount Vernon
B-
21.7
37Glen Cove
B-
21.7
38Sleepy Hollow
B-
21.8
39Gloversville
B-
22
40Olean
B-
22
41Lake Grove
B-
22
42Cortland
B-
22.1
43Westbury
B-
22.1
44Lockport
B-
22.3
45White Plains
B-
22.4
46Chestnut Ridge
B-
22.4
47Auburn
B-
22.5
48Utica
B-
22.8
49Canandaigua
B-
22.8
50Troy
B-
23
51Harrison
B-
23
52Corning
C+
23
53Ithaca
C+
23.1
54Haverstraw
C+
23.1
55Newburgh
C+
23.2
56Poughkeepsie
C+
23.3
57Middletown
C+
23.4
58Oneida
C+
23.4
59Mineola
C+
23.5
60Cohoes
C+
23.5
61Port Chester
C+
23.6
62Dunkirk
C+
23.6
63New Square
C+
23.6
64Oswego
C+
23.7
65Hempstead
C+
23.8
66New Hyde Park
C+
23.8
67Spring Valley
C+
23.9
68Dobbs Ferry
C+
23.9
69Scarsdale
C+
24
70Rye
C+
24
71Floral Park
C+
24.1
72Rochester
C+
24.5
73Albany
C+
24.5
74Jamestown
C+
24.5
75Buffalo
C+
24.7
76Lindenhurst
C+
24.7
77Tonawanda
C+
24.7
78Geneva
C+
24.7
79Rockville Centre
C+
24.8
80Elmira
C+
24.9
81Schenectady
C+
25
82Massapequa Park
C+
25
83Watervliet
C+
25.3
84Kiryas Joel
C+
25.8
85Ossining
C+
25.9
86Syracuse
C+
26
87Lackawanna
C+
26
88Amsterdam
C+
26.2
89Yonkers
C
26.9
90New Rochelle
C
27

Violent and property crime rates per 100,000 residents. FBI Uniform Crime Report data.

Most Dangerous Cities in New York

The highest crime rates among tracked cities in New York.

Safest Cities in Nearby States

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the safest city in New York?
As of 2026, West Haverstraw is the safest city in New York with a crime rate of 18.3 per 1,000 residents and a B safety grade. It ranks safer than 62% of all US cities. The violent crime rate is 296 per 100,000 (national average: 363.8).
What are the top 10 safest cities in New York?
Based on 2026 FBI Uniform Crime Report data, the top 10 safest cities in New York ranked by lowest crime rate are: West Haverstraw, Kenmore, Watertown, Babylon, Mount Kisco, New York, Peekskill, Lynbrook, Suffern, Long Beach. Rankings use combined violent and property crime rates per capita.
Is New York safe?
New York has a higher-than-average violent crime rate at 379 per 100K (national: 363.8). Safety varies widely by city — West Haverstraw earns a B grade while New Rochelle earns a C. 38 of 90 tracked cities have crime rates at or below the national average.
What is the most dangerous city in New York?
New Rochelle has the highest crime rate in New York at 27 per 1,000 residents, earning a C safety grade. Its violent crime rate is 464 per 100,000.
What is the average crime rate in New York?
The average crime rate across 90 tracked cities in New York is 22.5 per 1,000 residents (national average: 22.0). The average violent crime rate is 379 per 100K and property crime averages 1875 per 100K.
How are New York safety rankings calculated?
Rankings use FBI Uniform Crime Report data — the most comprehensive crime dataset in the US. Cities are graded A+ through F based on combined violent and property crime rates per capita, compared against national distributions. 90 cities in New York have sufficient data for ranking.

FBI Uniform Crime Report data and Census Bureau population estimates. Safety grades calculated using national and state-level crime rate distributions. Not a substitute for local law enforcement guidance.

Know before you go

CityCheck covers safety grades, crime data, cost of living, and things to do for every US city.

Explore cities